Now at the SCHIRN: Hans Haacke. Retrospective

10/25/2024

13 min reading time

Hans Haacke

A legend of institutional critique, an advocate of democracy, and an artist’s artist: the SCHIRN presents the groundbreaking work of the compelling contemporary artist Hans Haacke.

Lorem ipsum

The German-Amer­ican artist Hans Haacke (b. 1936) counts as one of the most influ­en­tial figures in contem­po­rary art. From November 8, 2024, to February 9, 2025, the SCHIRN is dedi­cating a compre­hen­sive retro­spec­tive to the artist’s oeuvre from 1959 to the present.

Haacke has shaped the devel­op­ment of polit­ical art like no other artist of his gener­a­tion. His direct and theo­ret­i­cally concise works are simul­ta­ne­ously poetic, metaphor­ical, ecolog­ical, and in many respects extremely contem­po­rary. On several occa­sions, his contro­ver­sial artistic contri­bu­tions to current debates were censored from exhi­bi­tions. Artis­ti­cally, he has pursued a variety of strate­gies, becoming involved early on in the fields of ecology and natural sciences, drawing on approaches from the ZERO group, Mini­malism, Concep­tual Art, public art, and poster art, among others. As a central pioneer of Insti­tu­tional Critique within Concep­tual Art, his works exam­ined orders or systems and presented them compar­a­tively. The artist himself describes the world as a super­system with count­less subsys­tems, each of which is more or less influ­enced by the others. Systemic thinking, insti­tu­tional critique, and democ­racy are the major themes running throughout Haacke’s oeuvre.

The SCHIRN is showing iconic early works from the 1960s, his influ­en­tial real-time systems, pieces that invite public partic­i­pa­tion, as well as expan­sive (histor­ical) polit­ical instal­la­tions. With around seventy paint­ings, photographs, objects, instal­la­tions, actions, posters, and a film, the exhi­bi­tion illus­trates how Haacke became one of the world’s most impor­tant and influ­en­tial polit­ical artists for subse­quent gener­a­tions.

Hans Haacke, Portrait of the artist, 2015
© Photo: Justin Tallis / AFP via Getty Images

Gift Horse” in the Rotunda

In her publicly acces­sible rotunda, the SCHIRN presents Hans Haacke’s iconic “Gift Horse” (2014), which the artist devel­oped for Trafalgar Square in London as part of the Fourth Plinth, one of the world’s most pres­ti­gious commis­sions for public art. As a kind of “counter-monu­ment” to the impe­rial repre­sen­ta­tion of power by the statues in this square, Haacke’s 4.5-meter-tall bronze sculp­ture shows a horse skeleton based on a study from George Stubbs’s book “The Anatomy of the Horse”. The ticker of the Frank­furt Stock Exchange is trans­mitted live via an elec­tronic display on a loop at the front of the skeleton’s thigh bone. Haacke’s “Gift Horse” can be read as a commen­tary on a society that has for centuries been defined by class antag­o­nisms and subjected to the dictates of the markets.

Hans Haacke, Gift Horse, 2014, Bronze with black patina and wax finish, stainless-steel fasteners and supports, and 5 mm flexible LED display with stainless-steel armature and polycarbonate face, 464.8 x 429.3 × 165.1 cm
Courtesy the artist and Paula Cooper Gallery, New York, © Hans Haacke / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2024, Photo: Hans Haacke

Between physics, biology and ecology

The exhi­bi­tion tour begins with impor­tant phys­ical, biolog­ical, and ecolog­ical works from the 1960s onward. Haacke’s early projects were influ­enced by his friend­ship with Otto Piene and his contact with the Düssel­dorf-based ZERO group. During this period, he partic­i­pated in numerous pioneering exhi­bi­tions on Kinetic Art, Op Art, Concep­tual Art, and Land Art. Although Haacke’s work had over­laps with many inno­v­a­tive move­ments of the 1960s, he did not feel that he really belonged to any of them. He wasn’t inter­ested in specific mate­rials or styles, but in the funda­mental connec­tions between phys­ical, biolog­ical, and social systems. The earliest works shown at the SCHIRN include the painting “Ce n’est pas la voie lactée (This Is Not the Milky Way)” (1960) and Haacke’s reliefs with mirror foil created starting in 1961. The latter already testi­fied to an interest in inter­ac­tions with the viewer, which would become increas­ingly impor­tant. Haacke’s first photo­graphic work, “Photo­graphic Notes, docu­menta 2” (1959), also depicts visitor behavior in exhi­bi­tion spaces. Other pieces, some of which are partic­i­pa­tory in nature, demon­strate phys­ical processes, such as “Column with Two Immis­cible Liquids” (1965) or “Large Water Level” (1964–65).

Hans Haacke, Photographic Notes, documenta 2, 1959, 26 b/w photographs selection), 16.8 × 25.1 cm each, Edition 2 of 3
Courtesy the artist and Paula Cooper Gallery, New York, © Hans Haacke / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2024, Photo: Hans Haacke

From object to process

Also on display is a series in which Haacke explored the various phys­ical states of water. One of the artist’s signa­ture works is the “Large Conden­sa­tion Cube” (1963–67), a cube of acrylic glass enclosing a small amount of water. Haacke also called these cubes “weather boxes” and later made analo­gies between mete­o­ro­log­ical and polit­ical climates. This linking of different systems is char­ac­ter­istic of Haacke’s method. The tran­si­tion from object (or sculp­ture) to process is also evident in his artistic prac­tice. Further “exper­i­mental setups” in the museum inte­rior demon­strate the water cycle (“Circu­la­tion”, 1969) by means of evap­o­ra­tion, conden­sa­tion, crys­tal­liza­tion, lique­fac­tion, other air move­ments (“Blue Sail”, 1964–65), or growth processes (“Grass Grows”, 1969). From 1967 on, Haacke also worked outdoors, for example with “Sky Line” (1967), and controlled processes related to water vapor or melting snow, which he then docu­mented photo­graph­i­cally.

Hans Haacke, Large Condensation Cube, 1963–67, Acrylic glass, distilled water, 76.2 x 76.2 x 76.2 cm
MACBA Collection, MACBA Foundation, Gift of National Comitee and Board of Trustees Whitney Museum of American Art, © Hans Haacke / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2024, Photo: Hans Haacke

Ecological art

He consis­tently returned to systemic and ecolog­ical ques­tions. His photo­graph “Monu­ment to Beach Pollu­tion” (1970) counts as one of the very first ecolog­ical works of art. With “Krefeld Sewage Trip­tych” (1972) and “Rhine Water Purifi­ca­tion Plant” (1972), Haacke offered direct and indicting commen­tary on the pollu­tion of the river Rhine. His “real-time systems” are also a distin­guishing feature of his oeuvre. The action “Chickens Hatching” (1969) saw chicks hatching in real time in the exhi­bi­tion space, demon­strating birth and growth processes in a mini­malist box struc­ture. “Ant Co-op” (1969) docu­ments the regu­larity of the tunnels dug by ants as a biolog­ical and social system. The docu­men­tary artist portrait “Hans Haacke: Self-Portrait of a German Artist in New York” (1969) offers insights into his artistic methods and also shows many early proces­sual works in action.

Hans Haacke, Monument to Beach Pollution, 1970, Slabs of construction material, plastic containers, and other detritus collected from a 200 × 50 cm stretch of beach and put in a pile, executed in Carboneras, Spain, C-print on aluminum, 51 × 76 cm
Courtesy the artist and Paula Cooper Gallery, New York, © Hans Haacke / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2024, Photo: Hans Haacke

Sociological-political works

One of the exhi­bi­tion’s areas of focus is the soci­o­log­ical and polit­ical approach that even­tu­ally became known as his signa­ture work. From 1969 onward, Haacke started analyzing and visu­al­izing social systems in order to spark sociopo­lit­ical debates in the art context. This form of Concep­tual Art is funda­men­tally about raising aware­ness for the social, economic, and insti­tu­tional condi­tions under which art is produced, exhib­ited, sold, and received. In 1971, “Shapolsky et al. Manhattan Real Estate Hold­ings, a Real-Time Social System, as of May 1, 1971” trig­gered a cultural-polit­ical scandal and artistic protests against censor­ship. Using photographs, tabular infor­ma­tion, and plans of 142 prop­er­ties on the Lower East Side and in the Harlem district of Manhattan, Haacke exposed the dubious concen­tra­tion of real estate and related prac­tices of the Shapolsky group. This work led the director of the Guggen­heim Museum, Thomas Messer, to cancel Haacke’s solo exhi­bi­tion shortly before it was sched­uled to open.

Hans Haacke, Shapolsky et al. Manhattan Real Estate Holdings, a Real-Time Social System, as of May 1, 1971, 1971, b/w photographs, typewritten maps, 20.5 × 31 cm each diptych, Edition 2/2
© MACBA Collection, MACBA Foundation / Whitney Museum of American Art, © Hans Haacke / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2024, Photo: Hans Haacke

Institutional critique

“Manet-PROJEKT ’74” (1974), which Haacke submitted for the anniver­sary exhi­bi­tion of the Wallraf Richartz Museum in Cologne, also prompted another act of insti­tu­tional censor­ship. He proposed exhibiting Édouard Manet’s “Bunch of Asparagus” (1880) from the museum’s collec­tion along­side the results of his own research into the work’s prove­nance. The infor­ma­tion panels contain detailed personal, biograph­ical, profes­sional, and finan­cial infor­ma­tion on the previous owners, as well as infor­ma­tion about their involve­ment in National Socialism. The SCHIRN is also showing two further pieces that crit­i­cally examine the entan­gle­ments between art patronage and economic activity: “Der Prali­nen­meister (The Choco­late Master)” (1981), about the connec­tions between cultural and tax-related deci­sions made by the influ­en­tial Cologne collector and manu­fac­turer Peter Ludwig, and “Buhr­lesque” (1985) on the Swiss art collector, patron, and arms manu­fac­turer Dr. Diet­rich Bührle.

Hans Haacke, Der Pralinenmeister (The Chocolate Master), 1981, collage of multicolor silkscreen prints, photographs, chocolates, and chocolate wrappers, 100 × 70 cm each, Museum Ludwig, Cologne
© Rheinisches Bildarchiv Köln, rba_d048571_1 / Museum Ludwig Köln, Grafische Sammlung / Hans Haacke / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2024, Photo: Sabrina Walz

Participation

The exhi­bi­tion also presents partic­i­pa­tory works, such as the instal­la­tion “MoMA Poll” (1970) in which Haacke asked visi­tors to The Museum of Modern Art in New York ques­tions about their polit­ical convic­tions. A new visitor survey will also be conducted during the exhi­bi­tion at the SCHIRN. In “Photo­elec­tric Viewer-Controlled Coor­di­nate System” (1968), the visi­tors’ move­ments through the room trigger infrared projec­tors and photo­elec­tric sensors that vari­ously acti­vate twenty-eight light bulbs.

Democracy and opinion forming

In numerous pieces, Haacke advo­cated for demo­c­ratic processes, the acti­va­tion of public opinion, and a pluralist anti-fascist approach. Some of his projects deal with media repre­sen­ta­tion: “News” (1969) trans­plants the ticker of a news agency into the exhi­bi­tion space; in the SCHIRN, reports from selected Frank­furt media such as the Frank­furter Allge­meine Zeitung, the Frank­furter Rund­schau, and Hessen­schau.de are trans­mitted. “Photo Oppor­tu­nity (After the Storm / Walker Evans)” (1992) offers a compar­a­tive perspec­tive on photo reportage. The SCHIRN is also showing Haacke’s power-crit­ical work for docu­menta 7. The instal­la­tion “Oil Painting: Homage to Marcel Broodthaers” (1982) consists of a portrait of then US Pres­i­dent Ronald Reagan made by Haacke himself, which is shown oppo­site a large-format photo­graph of a major demon­stra­tion by oppo­nents of his poli­cies and the deploy­ment of nuclear weapons.

Hans Haacke, News, 1969, Teletype machine, paper, wire service, variable dimensions, Edition 2/3
Courtesy the artist and Paula Cooper Gallery, New York, © Hans Haacke / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2024, Photo: Ellen Wilson

The German past and present

Haacke’s long-standing engage­ment with the poli­tics of history and post-Nazism also feature in the exhi­bi­tion. In 1993, he repre­sented the German Pavilion at the Venice Bien­nale, for which he was awarded the Golden Lion together with Nam June Paik. His sensa­tional contri­bu­tion “GERMANIA” presented a debris field of marble floor slabs inside the room, which had been remod­eled in 1939 under the National Social­ists. Haacke devel­oped the large-scale work “DER BEVÖLKERUNG (TO THE POPU­LA­TION)” (2000) as a perma­nent instal­la­tion for one of the two inner court­yards of the German Reich­stag building in Berlin. The deci­sion to award the commis­sion to Haacke became the subject of inten­sive public debates in the Bundestag. The illu­mi­nated letters installed on the floor refer to the inscrip­tion “DEM DEUTSCHEN VOLKE” (To The German People) on the gable of the Reich­stag building. Each member of the Bundestag was invited to contribute 50 kilo­grams of soil from their constituency; the seeds embedded in the soil grew into a variety of living vege­ta­tion, which now frames the letters today. Haacke’s poster project “We (All) Are the People”, which was created for docu­menta 14 (2017) in Kassel and Athens and has since been shown many times, can be read as a reac­tion to the rise of anti-migrant senti­ment in recent decades. The text-based poster work repeats the epony­mous slogan in the twelve different languages of the major migrant groups in each country.

Hans Haacke, GERMANIA, German Pavilion, Venice Biennale, 1993
Courtesy the artist and Paula Cooper Gallery, New York, © Hans Haacke / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2024, Photo: Hans Haacke
Hans Haacke, DER BEVÖLKERUNG (TO THE POPULATION, 2000, View of the installation DER BEVÖLKERUNG in the northern atrium of the Reichstag building in Berlin, 2008, C-print on aluminum, 232 × 178 cm
Courtesy the artist and Sfeir-Semler Gallery, Beirut / Hamburg, © Hans Haacke / VG Bild-Kunst, Bonn 2024, Photo: Stefan Müller

You may also like

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consetetur sadipscing elitr, sed diam nonumy eirmod tempor invidunt.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit